Modern times in Copenhagen

It was time to order tickets again, for yet another last Dylan show I’d ever go to. I usually do that, and probably will for as long as he stays on the road. Thinking that it’s the last time, adds a certain nostalgic undertone to the experience.
After the past few years of mediocrity, the expectations were low. I can’t say I was overly prepared either, but at least I knew that the band was the same as the one I’d seen a year and a half ago, and that didn’t bode well.
Then there was the new album… A good one, for sure — must be, since it could bring the old bard to the top of all the charts in the world. Some people had voiced misgivings about the legitimacy of the phrase “All songs written by Bob Dylan”, but hey, he’s a genius, right, so he must be right, right?

There’s one scenario under which the Copenhagen show was a huge disappointment. That’s the scenario where I had been hoping for a bad show to match the previous ones, so that I could write here: “Dylan’s Dead” or something, and then sit back and enjoy all the comments; it would have been a nice way to boost the activity around here.

Luckily that didn’t happen. It was a good show and a good experience. That’s not because the band was great — I don’t think they are. George Receli on drums is the exception; I like his style (and his beret). And Tony Garnier does what he’s supposed to, of course — neither more nor less. But the rest of them… I understand that they are great musicians, but one can’t claim that they show it. The guy on the left — Don Freeman? — played some run-of-the-mill solos once in a while, lost his way in the chord sequences a couple of times, fell out of rhythm, and (so it seemed) got a few angry looks from the boss. The other guitar player was fairly anonymous — the only reason I noticed him at all, was because he played a nice Gibson J-45 … :-)
But I’ll leave that aside, because, as I said, it was a very pleasant musical experience all the same, and that’s all because of Mr D himself. If we compare this year’s show with previous ones, we get:

Then Now
All song lines reduced to single tones with ridiculous octave leap at the end Melodious, inventive singing with a clear sense of melodic direction, and a nice level of variation
Toy piano; barely audible; barely used as anything more than a drum kit Organ sound; clearly audible, revealing some nice counter-melodies
No guitar Guitar

The singing — What a relief it was, not to be dragged through an hour and a half of “justlikea-woman“, “how does it feel?“, “Desolation row” — all on the same two tones. Only a handful of times were there reminiscences of that mannerism, which was infrequent enough for it to be perceived as an effect and not just as a throat condition or a lack of inspiration.
I don’t know for certain that Dylan is more inspired now — that’s not for me to judge either — but his singing definitely was.
Then the keyboard instrument — It was fun to hear the piano when he first started playing it in 2003, but I’m not sure how much it contributed. I’m not saying that it was bad. His way of using it stands in a respectable tradition going back at least to Bela Bartok, who also saw the piano as a percussion instrument. But one couldn’t hear much of it, other than the occasional bangs.
The organ sound he uses now is a different matter. It carries through more clearly, so one can hear what he plays, and — lo and behold! — it’s good! There were several occasions where he definitely had some nice interplay going on between improvisational figures in the singing and in the playing at the same time. Not at all trivial, not at all the three-note solos he is famed for, but real integration between several different musical strands. Enough to make this old contrapuntist’s heart melt…
The sound itself is also interesting. I don’t know exactly how to describe it (and I can’t remember exactly either), but the associations I got from it were somewhere between a hammond organ and a chapel organ. This goes well with the two styles that Dylan has explored a little more than usual during the 2000s: the swing jazz style of “Love & Theft” and Modern Times and the hymns like Rock of Ages and Pass Me Not, O Gentle Savior.
I have this recording of Stephen Foster’s Hard Times, known to most from Dylan’s Good As I Been To You, but available in quite different versions. This one has a women’s choir singing to the accompaniment of a pump organ, quite like the sounds Dylan produced during “When The Deal Goes Down” off Modern Times. There is no reason to assume that this is what Dylan has had in mind, but during that song, I raced through a chain of associations in my mind, from Bing Crosby’s slow and sentimental “Where the Blue of the Night” which is the basis of the song, through Dylan’s own version “When the Deal Goes Down”, to Stephen Foster and the women’s choir. That is some span to cover just in an organ accompaniment, and I would probably call it an overinterpretation, if it wasn’t for the fact that it matches so well Dylan’s own musical universe, where sugary-tender Tin Pan Alley goes hand in hand with religious hymns and Civil War balladry.

I welcome the stronger singing, the new instrument sounds, and the stylistical melting pot. If only he could get a more interesting band…

9 thoughts on “Modern times in Copenhagen

  1. Hi
    I agree with most of what you say. I saw him Glasgow last month and thought the singing was great, but I thought the band worked really well. I actually prefer the sound than the Love and Theft line up, but I think its just an aesthertic preference.
    One thing i wanted to ask though was whether it was definately Bob getting that organ sound. I was quite far away from the stage in Glasgow but thought there was maybe another guy on a keyboard type instrument, but i could be wrong. if it was Bob, it was pretty impressive!!

  2. I saw the Copenhagen show as well, it was my first and it was great. I can’t believe he actually played Desolation and Visions both the same night, two of my favourites. And yes, it most definately was bob on the organ.

  3. I got front and centre tickets for the Melbourne August show. Its my first time seeing Bob so Im really looking forward to it and now I hear hes picked up his act I cant wait!

  4. I am a rabid, 58 year old, long term fan that was disappointed, to say the least, at the last Toronto concert (my first). No guitar (I understand he had a problem with his arm?) and not much keyboard either. And as you put it so well, the ridiculous octave jumping at the last note of each line drove me nuts. I am really happy to hear he seems to be getting it back together. Maybe worth ‘one more’ Dylan concert.

  5. Just saw Dylan last night in Quebec city, great concert I must say, 4th row and loving it. Picked up his strat from the start, played 4 songs in a row and went on his keyboard for the rest of the night. Changed most of the endings of all his songs to make them sound more melodious but I’m guessing he was preparing for tonight’s performance at Wilfred-Pelletier, Montreal. Part of the jazz fest we have going on every summer. Can’t wait to hear the reviews tomorrow in the paper, and my uncle renting on about how he’s got 2nd row tickets!!!

  6. Yep, know where you are coming from with the last show thing. I am 56 and Bob is 66 and when he recently visited Australia I saw 3 shows with that same feeling of not knowing if it was the last tour I see. Love ya work and thanks for ALL the stuff you have given over time.

  7. I saw him last night in albany ny. The band sounded great. I thought it was Bob Dylan and the boogie woogie band. I wished he had done more of his old stuff. He did do, Don’t think twice, Simple twist of fate, Hiway 61 [sounded great] and a few others. His new stuff sounded good and I will be buying a few from itunes. His voice is not what it used to be but I’m glad he is still around.

  8. I agree – the London concert, 15th, I think, was …….. almost very good. But, the band were disappointing, particularly being in search of a a guitarist. Denny lacked inventiveness and just the same – lost his way once or twice, though not many appeared to notice.


    I’ve just listened to the Syracuse 8/10 concert and the band, including Denny, as well as Bob, are really cooking. I guess it makes sense to use the European tour as a warm up of the US!

    Working Man’s Blues #2 is the highlight for me.

  9. I was at that Syracuse show, and, though it was tough to hear every lick from the fourth row, I thought the band was having a good night. It looked like Tony was smiling for Dylan at certain points, and you could see some subtle hand motions from the keyboard, which I thought was interesting.

    I really liked the new (new to me, at least) arrangement of Positively 4th Street. It’s quite nice, especially with the harmonica break towards the end.

    And, of course, Workingman’s Blues #2 was the one I was waiting for, and I was not disappointed, not one bit. It was awesome, seeing him lean in on the microphone and belt “Workingmaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan’s Blues…”

Leave a Reply to Filthy Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *